Saltwater vs Chlorine Pool: Which is Best for Your Backyard?

/ Uncategorized / By

Let’s put the great pool debate to rest once and for all. You’re standing in your own backyard, daydreaming of summer gatherings and midnight dips, when the question strikes: Do I go with saltwater or chlorine? It’s not merely which one smells nicer (although your nose will appreciate you breaking out the saltwater). Your wallet, maintenance schedule, and even the sensation of your skin after a swim depend on this choice.

Here’s the thing that most pool shops won’t share: there is no single answer. Saltwater pools deliver smooth, chemical-minimal water, but include corrosion threats in Vegas’ hard water. Chlorine pools are inexpensive at the onset, but require weekly chemical babysitting in our blistering sun. And surprise—both systems technically utilize chlorine! The question is: Which system suits your lifestyle, wallet, and backyard?

After installing and maintaining both types for over 40 years in Las Vegas, we’re debunking the saltwater vs chlorine pool debate with desert-specific facts. There is no marketing fluff—only true pricing, upkeep realities, and which system we would choose for our own houses.

1. Why This Decision Matters

Your backyard pool is not only a water element—it’s your personal retreat, Saturday afternoon hangout, and family fun zone. Choosing the right type of pool for the backyard requires weighing upfront cost, maintenance, health and comfort, and even eco-friendliness. Let’s get down to basics so you can have your answer at last: Do I want a saltwater or chlorine pool?

2. The Difference Between a Saltwater and a Chlorine Pool

How Saltwater Pools Work

Contrary to rumor, saltwater pools are not chlorine-free. You add pool-grade salt (~3,000 ppm) and a chlorine generator (also known as a salt chlorinator) turns the salt into chlorine when needed. The payoff? A softer, more consistent level of sanitizer in your water.

How Chlorine Pools Work

With a chlorine pool, you add liquid, granular, or tablet chlorine manually. You dose, test, and fine-tune weekly—here, you’re manipulating sanitizer levels directly instead of producing it on-site.

3. Saltwater Pool vs. Chlorine Pool Pros and Cons

Pros of Saltwater Pools

  • Lower Chemical Costs: Salt runs about $10–$20 per 40 lb bag; you rarely buy traditional chlorine.
  • Gentler Water: Fewer harsh chemicals = less red‑eye, softer skin, and no bleached swimwear.
  • Auto‑Sanitizing: The generator maintains residual chlorine, so you’ll do less “shock” work.
  • Smoother Feel: Many swimmers say saltwater feels more “silky” than chlorinated water.

Cons of Saltwater Pools

  • Higher Upfront Investment: Salt generators cost $500–$2,000 to purchase and install.
  • Corrosive Environment: Salt corrodes metals, pavers, and even pool equipment—more sealing and periodic hardware replacement are to be expected.
  • Power Draw: Many owners run filtration 24/7 to feed the generator, bumping up electricity bills.
  • Generator Maintenance: Cells last 3–7 years and cost $200–$800 to replace.

Pros of Chlorine Pools

  • Lower Initial Cost: No expensive equipment—just your standard pump, filter, and chemical feeder or floaters.
  • DIY Friendly: Pick up chlorine tablets or liquid, dose on your schedule, no generator to worry about.
  • Non‑Corrosive: Chlorine won’t rust metal pool ladders or damage stone decking.

Cons of Chlorine Pools

  • Ongoing Chemical Expense: Annual chlorine & shock can run $500–$1,500, depending on use and pool size.
  • Skin & Eye Irritation: Higher chlorine peaks can sting eyes and dry out skin.
  • Storage & Handling: You’ll need a safe space to stock up on strong chemicals and handle them regularly.

4. Cost Comparison: Installation & Maintenance

Upfront Costs

  • Saltwater Pool Conversion: $2,000–$3,000 total (chlorinator, wiring, labor).
  • Chlorine Pool Setup: $200–$500 for a basic chlorinator and dispenser.

Annual Maintenance Expenses

  • Saltwater Pools: Salt + cell cleanings ≈ $50–$100/year; cell replacement every 5–7 years ($200–$800).
  • Chlorine Pools: Chlorine & shock chemicals ≈ $500–$1,500/year; test kits $30–$50.

Although salt systems are more expensive initially, year-one maintenance may be 75% less, and within 5 years, you usually break even or save money.

5. Health, Comfort & Water Quality

  • Saltwater Pools: Lower chlorine spikes mean fewer irritations. Great for families with kids or anyone with sensitive skin.
  • Chlorine Pools: You control sanitizer levels directly, which can be ideal if you like dialing up shock treatments after heavy use.

Either way, both pools need weekly test kits for pH, chlorine, alkalinity, and stabilizer. Regular testing keeps the water clear, safe, and algae-free.

6. Environmental & Energy Considerations

  • Saltwater Pools: Continuous filtration to power the chlorinator equals higher energy use—plan on 10–24 hours of daily pump runtime.
  • Chlorine Pools: You can optimize filter cycles (8–12 hours/day) for cost savings, making chlorine systems slightly greener, provided you don’t over‑treat.

Both systems can gain from solar covers (reduce evaporation by ~95%), LED pool lights, and variable‑speed pumps to reduce your carbon footprint and energy cost.

7. How to Choose Between a Saltwater and a Chlorine Pool

Ask yourself:

  1. Budget: Can you absorb $2,000+ now to save later?
  2. Comfort: Is fuss‑free, gentle water worth avoiding weekly chemical dosing?
  3. Environment: Do you mind extra electricity usage to run a chlorinator?
  4. Longevity: Will metal and stone near your pool handle salt’s corrosive touch?
  5. DIY vs. Pro: Prefer hands‑on maintenance or hands‑off automation?

If low‑maintenance luxury is your priority—and you can afford the up-front cost—saltwater is your solution. If control, reduced energy consumption, and chlorine dosing don’t bother you, keep it traditional.

8. When DIY Works—and When to Call the Pros

  • DIY: Day‑to‑day chemical balancing, skimming, and brushing you can handle in an afternoon.
  • Pro Help: Salt chlorinator electrical installation, extensive repairs, or labor-intensive cell cleaning—always best performed by licensed service people.

A good service provider can save you thousands in mistakes and keep your system humming.

9. Bonus: Alternative Sanitizing Systems

Beyond the salt vs. chlorine debate, consider:

  • UV Systems: UV light kills pathogens; it still requires minimal chlorine.
  • Ozone Generators: Ozone oxidizes contaminants; excellent for heavy‑use commercial pools.
  • Mineral Systems: Copper‑silver ionizers reduce chemical needs but rarely eliminate chlorine completely.

These can supplement—or in some cases replace—traditional sanitizers for ultra‑low‑chemistry swimming.

10. Conclusion: Should I Get a Saltwater or Chlorine Pool?

  • Choose Saltwater. If you want a softer swim, low chemical dosing, and don’t mind a higher initial cost, along with occasional corrosion issues.
  • Choose Chlorine. If you prefer lower installation costs, accurate chemical control, and a system that’s easier on the bill and metalware.

Each choice provides crystal-clear water when kept up. Your ultimate backyard pool is all about finding the balance of budget, comfort, and DIY hunger. Whatever you choose, listen to our pool maintenance advice, keep on top of testing, and your new haven will pay you back for years to come.

Are you ready to properly update or maintain your pool? Since 1981, Nationwide Pool has helped thousands of Las Vegas homeowners choose (and convert) their ideal pool system. We’ll evaluate your backyard, budget, and habits to recommend what works, not simply what sells. Contact Nationwide Pool now for expert advice on keeping your backyard splashing all season!